Hadith 597

(1) The statement: "Nor tendons." In response to Al-Radd al-Muhtar, it is stated: "The tendons of a dead animal are considered pure according to the well-known opinion," meaning the purity of the tendons, as affirmed in "Al-Wiqayah" and "Al-Durr," among others. It was even mentioned in "Al-Bada'i" and followed in "Al-Fath" that there is no disagreement on this. However, it was criticized in "Al-Bahr" where "Al-Ghayat al-Bayan" mentioned two opinions: one stating it is pure because it is considered bone, and the other stating it is impure because it contains life, and sensory perception can occur through it. The second opinion was confirmed in "Al-Siraj."

(۱) قوله: ولا عصب وقال في رد المحتار: وعصبها أي الميتة طاهر على المشهور، أي من طهارة العصب، كما جزم به في «الوقاية» و«الدر»، وغيرهما، بل ذكر في البدائع وتبعه في «الفتح» أنه لا خلاف فيه، لكن تعقبه في «البحر» بأنه في «غاية البيان ذكر فيه روايتين، إحداهما : أنه طاهر؛ لأنه عظم. والأخرى أنه نجس؛ لأن فيه حياة، والحس يقع به، وصحح في «السراج» الثانية.