Hadith 588

(1) [Narrated by Al-Daraqutni from the hadith of Thabit bin Hammad, from Ali bin Zayd, from Sa'id bin al-Musayyib, from Ammar. Ali bin Zayd is Narrated by Muslim along with others, and Al-‘Ajli said there is no harm in him, and his narrations are written. Al-Hakim also narrated it in his "Mustadrak." Al-Tirmidhi said he was trustworthy. As for Thabit bin Hammad, no one accused him of fabrication except Al-Bayhaqi, although Al-Bayhaqi mentioned him in "Al-Ma'rifah" without attributing the accusation of fabrication. Al-Daraqutni and Ibn 'Adi said similar things. Al-Bazzar said Thabit bin Hammad was reliable, but there is no knowledge of him narrating anything except this hadith. He had a supporting narrator, and it was also narrated by Al-Tabarani in his "Al-Mu'jam Al-Kabir," where [Narrated by Ibrahim. This was stated by the scholar Al-‘Aini in his explanation of "Al-Hidayah."

(۱) قوله: رواه الدار قطني من حديث ثابت بن حماد عن علي بن زيد، عن سعيد بن المسيب، عن عمار الحديث. علي بن زيد روى له مسلم مقرونا به، وقال العجلي: لا بأس به. وفي موضع آخر يكتب حديثه، وروى له الحاكم في «المستدرك». وقال الترمذي: صدوق، وأما ثابت فلم يتهمه أحد بالوضع غير البيهقي، مع أنه ذكره في كتابه «المعرفة» ولم ينسبه إلى الوضع. وإنما حكي فيه قول الدار قطني وابن عدي، وقال البزار: وثابت بن حماد كان ثقة، ولا يعرف أنه روى غير هذا الحديث، وله متابع، ورواه الطبراني في معجمه الكبير، وفيه إبراهيم. قاله العلامة العيني في شرح الهداية».